If you have the stomach for it, my new book, “The Grim Old Days: An Introduction to the Preindustrial Past,” takes the reader on a tour of a thankfully lost world of bloodletting, filth, destitution, and famine-induced cannibalism.

By making vivid the harsh realities of life before economic growth, the book dispels the romanticization of the past found among degrowth advocates who say they want to shrink the economy, as well as those who dismiss the value of market-driven economic growth and put up government barriers to block the entrepreneurs and technological innovations behind it.

From policymakers imposing data center construction moratoria and risking the country’s technological edge in the AI race to city regulators blocking the deployment of self-driving cars that could save many of the nearly 40,000 lives lost each year in traffic accidents, overregulation threatens future progress at every turn. 

If the AI revolution is seen as a new Industrial Revolution, the latter’s dismal public image could create further opposition to AI and more government roadblocks. Many believe industrialization enriched a wealthy few while leaving ordinary people no better off—or even poorer, as historian Howard Zinn argues in his bestselling history textbook, echoing Marx’s “immiseration” thesis. 

The mistaken belief that economic growth fails to improve living standards fuels skepticism about its value. The Democratic Socialists of America—whose members include Congresswomen Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Rashida Tlaib as well as New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani—in its official publication, the “Democratic Forum,” has flirted with degrowth and critiqued “Capitalism’s insatiable need for growth.” 

Left-wing French presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon has called to “establish new indicators of human progress” in lieu of gross domestic product and, during a recent campaign rally, mocked the value of GDP as an indicator: “I dig a hole, GDP goes up. I fill it in, GDP goes up.”

Economic history can be summarized in a famous “hockey-stick chart”: a long flat line of barely perceptible progress bordering on stagnation, and then a sudden, jarring upswing representing exponential growth, starting around the time of industrialization.

This massive increase in wealth throughout the world over the last two and a half centuries is frequently dismissed: What does a line in a graph mean for the average person? On the internet, memes receive thousands of likes by mocking the idea that the line holds any positive significance, dismissing the concept, with intentionally poor grammar, as “line go up, means things gooder.” 

But greater prosperity does mean longer lives, better nutrition and sanitation, and improved environmental stewardship. This line represents children living to celebrate more birthdays, more time with loved ones, and more years with grandchildren. It’s hard to convey how much a trend line can matter.

A popular myth about life before the Industrial Revolution and the upswing in GDP is that people lived a simple, peaceful existence, close to nature and each other.

In reality, around half of all children died before adulthood, hunger was common, violence against women was widely accepted, animals were routinely abused, average life expectancy was in the 30s, and barely one in 10 people was literate. Peasants doing subsistence farm work made up the vast majority of the population and endured conditions unthinkable to those of us today fortunate enough to enjoy postindustrial prosperity. “The Grim Old Days” offers a journey through their world.

If the AI revolution is in fact a new industrial revolution, its potential to improve living standards is extraordinary. But if overregulation holds back the industry and the wider economy, we risk squandering prosperity our forebears could scarcely have imagined. History offers a chilling warning against taking prosperity for granted.