On September 15, the U.S. House Committee on Education and the Workforce Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions held its final hearing ahead of the November 2026 midterms entitled, “Out of Touch: When Union Politics Leave Workers Behind.”
Chairman Rick Allen (R-GA12) called witnesses:
- Thomas Jones, President of the American Accountability Foundation in D.C.;
- Askash Chougule, President of the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity (FREOPP);
- Dr. Adam Dean, Associate Professor of Political Science at George Washington University; and
- Greg Murad, VP of Federal Affairs at the National Right to Work Committee.
While the hearing should have involved a pivotal and productive conversation on how labor unions can course-correct in order to benefit both union membership and worker satisfaction, it instead became an exercise in both sides talking past each other without reaching any concrete solutions on how workers’ protections and benefits can work in balance with right-to-work and worker freedoms.
Several Democrats on the committee insisted that unions are more popular than ever. Rep. Mark Takano (D-CA41) and Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA06) claimed during their five-minute questioning period that an attack on unions is an attack on working families. But how can that be when only 6% of Americans belong to a private-sector union?
Takano claimed that the reason why so few workers are in unions is that employers make it difficult for them to organize or violate labor law to prevent them from doing so. Takano used his time to advocate for two bills: the Protecting the Right to Organize Act (PRO) Act, which seeks to unionize as many workers as possible, including independent contractors, and remove right-to-work laws; and the Let’s Protect Workers Act, which would increase penalties on labor law violations. These penalties would adversely affect small businesses, and backdoors the destruction of independent professionals’ rights to work for themselves.
Takano and his Democrat colleagues, along with witness Dr. Dean, failed to answer key questions, primarily: If unions are so popular, why can they not break that logjam of a 6% member base?
An examination of why Big Labor loses membership each year would have greatly benefitted the discourse. It also would have been right to acknowledge the documented corruption caused by union bosses and their inappropriate excesses at the rank-and-file’s expense.
Instead, FREOPP’s Chougule and NRTW’s Murad presented evidence on how unions aggressively target right-to-work states, creating laws to limit or remove these protections. Unions also spend time and dues money harassing and suing the very workers they claim to protect if a worker calls them out for their misuse of union funds for political purposes or if a worker wants to separate from the union.
Another item that was not addressed: why lawmakers, both Republicans and Democrats, handed the unions a gift in the Faster Labor Contracts Act. This bill has cleared the House of Representatives, and if passed by the Senate, would give labor bosses a powerful new tool to impose on workplaces diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) mandates, enforce transgender workplace policies, and restrict cooperation with immigration enforcement, all of this without the workers’ vote or consent.
How does this strengthen workers’ bargaining powers, benefits, or protections?
Chougule made this pivotal point in his opening statement:
To allege that greater freedom, transparency, and accountability within labor organizations undermines the right to organize or engage in political speech is false.
Chougule also pointed to the lack of support by unions and certain representatives on the Employment and the Workforce Committee, for the Employee Rights Act. The Act would require unions to obtain opt-in permission from a member before using his or her dues and fees on political activity or policy advocacy—a provision which enjoys 81% support from union households.
Chougule said,
Whether it’s protecting workers’ privacy in unionization campaigns (80% union household support), ensuring independent contractors’ ability to set their own hours (77% union household support), or any of its other policies, the Employee Rights Act delivers reforms that union members back. Yet I am not aware of any labor union that backs the bill.
Mourad also offered some solutions:
There is one fix that reaches all of it: Make union support voluntary. The twin pillars of union power are monopoly bargaining and forced dues. Congress created this problem when it passed the National Labor Relations Act in 1935, and it is up to Congress to solve it. A union that has to ask for workers’ support instead of compelling, it is a union that will have to listen to its workers.
Rep. Burgess Owens (R-UT04) stated plainly, “This is not about union or non-union; it’s about how our money is being used.”
Owens referred to the AFL-CIO crafting a resolution, without member consent, demanding a cease-fire in Gaza. Mourad confirmed that they assisted several Jewish union members in filing lawsuits.
The AFL-CIO ultimately rescinded the resolution.
Chogoule reflected on the adversarial relationship that the 1935 National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) created, and why it is no longer conducive to a 21st-century workforce.
I think the model of 1935 relies on a significant amount of animosity between workers and employers that I just don’t think is reflective, as the Chairman alluded to, for many workers today. One of the members of the minority raised the point about affordability being a major concern. The data has shown, and my testimony alludes to the Mercatus Center’s analysis that, oftentimes, voluntary unionism, less rigid structures, can actually help workers financially in the long run through greater investment, greater job growth.
Chogoule also asserted that the attacks by unions on right-to-work states are misguided:
Right-to-Work states, for example, enjoy greater real growth and disposable personal income, higher cost-of-living-adjusted per capita disposable income, lower rates of welfare dependency. And, so, the economic gains of worker freedom have been apparent for many, many years at the state level.
Workers’ demand that they have a say in what their unions do on their behalf, and that unions be accountable for the money they spend should not be considered an attack on unionization. The freedom for workers to opt out of a union should also not be beyond the pale.
Waning membership and unions’ refusal to recalibrate will remain an issue as the 119th Congress closes out its legislative year. Just as in 2025, when the House Committee on Employment and the Workforce made strides to bring the 80-year-old labor law in line with the 21st century.
With the balance of power potentially changing after the November midterm elections, it is unclear whether this work can continue. What is clear is that the American economy and workforce continue to be transformed through entrepreneurship and innovation, and unions and the workforce will ultimately have to adapt to this new paradigm or die.
